Wednesday, November 24, 2010

Privacy Groups Fault Online Health Sites for Sharing User Data With Marketers

By NATASHA SINGER  NY Yimes  11/24/2010

QualityHealth is a popular health Web site with more than 20 million registered users that offers online medical information and e-mail newsletters on a variety of topics, including diabetes, allergies, asthma and arthritis.

But according to a complaint filed Tuesday with the Federal Trade Commission, site visitors who provide personal details about themselves might not be aware that QualityHealth collects information about people’s medical conditions, preferred medicines and treatment plans and uses it to profile its users for prescription drug marketing.

Rob Rebak, the chief executive of QualityHealth, a company also known as Marketing Technology Solutions of Delaware, did not return a request for comment.

QualityHealth is one of a number of companies cited in the complaint to the F.T.C. filed by four nonprofit privacy and consumer advocacy groups. In the complaint, the Center for Digital Democracy, U.S. PIRG, Consumer Watchdog and the World Privacy Forum charged that online marketing of medications, products and medical services posed fundamental new risks to consumer privacy and health because of sophisticated data collection and patient-profiling techniques.

Asserting that such techniques are unfair and deceptive, the groups asked the F.T.C. to investigate the health marketing used by some popular sites including Google, HealthCentral, Everyday Health, WebMD and Sermo, a site for medical professionals.

Some sites, the complaint said, were not transparent enough about how they tracked people through users’ online heath searches and discussions or how they categorized and marketed to their conditions. Other sites may not be entirely open about how they create and use data profiles about users or blur the line between independent and sponsored content, the complaint said.

The concern, said Ed Mierzwinski, the consumer program director at U.S. PIRG, is not just about data mining and marketing that could influence patients to seek drugs they do not need or to spend more money on branded drugs rather than generics. More broadly, employers or health insurers could gain access to the consumers’ data profiles, leading to potential problems or penalties against the consumer, he said.

“You could be searching for health information about your cat or your neighbor and it could end up harming your health care in terms of denial or increased cost,” Mr. Mierzwinski said. “If people knew what kind of surveillance, eavesdropping and data mining were being used to collect information about you, encourage your use of prescription drugs and essentially use you as a research guinea pig, I think people would think twice.”

The complaint comes at a delicate moment for online and social media marketing of medical products and services. The Food and Drug Administration, which oversees drug marketing, is developing industry guidelines for digital and social media. In a two-day agency hearing on the subject last winter, many health sites, drug makers and marketing firms promoted the idea of digital health as a tool that empowered consumers, allowing patients to easily access medical information and form supportive interactive communities with other patients.

“There are clear public health benefits for health care providers and patients to be able to access truthful, scientifically accurate and F.D.A.-regulated information about medicines online from the companies that research and develop them,” said Jeffrey K. Francer, assistant general counsel of the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, an industry trade group. His group is still reviewing the complaint, he said.

But Jeff Chester, the executive director of the Center for Digital Democracy, said that the industry had provided the F.D.A with a “fairy-tale version of digital health marketing.”
Online data collection techniques give “pharmaceutical companies and health marketers a kind of digital X-ray of a health consumer’s concerns, fears and behaviors,” Mr. Chester said. “There is no meaningful disclosure of how that data is collected and used.”

A notice at the bottom of QualityHealth’s member registration form, for example, provides a link to the site’s privacy policy. The policy explains that information that may or may not identify someone may be used for ads aimed at consumers.

But QualityHealth provides greater detail about its methods in its pitch to business clients — like how the site uses tailored messages, informed by patient profiling, to prompt members to seek prescriptions for specific brands from their doctors.

“We can reach consumers just before their next doctor visit,” the site says, “as well as follow up with reminders and relevant information, for maximum impact.”

The site’s privacy policy states that the company is committed to providing consumers with clear notice and choice about its practices and that visitors are asked to opt in to the company’s data use policy.

Adam Grossberg, a spokesman for WebMD, said that WebMD had always been transparent and direct with its users. “All sponsored content on our site is clearly labeled as such, he said.” He added that the company could not comment on the specifics of the complaint because it had not received it.

A spokesman for Google said the company declined to comment for this article. HealthCentral, Everyday Health and Sermo did not respond to requests for comment.

The groups decided to file their complaint with the F.T.C., Mr. Chester said, because it oversees consumer privacy issues and because, the groups believed that the F.D.A., which has long overseen traditional marketing of drugs in print, radio and television, lacked the staff and the expertise to oversee online and social media drug marketing. An F.D.A. spokeswoman said the agency planned to review the complaint.

David Vladeck, the director of the F.T.C.’s bureau on consumer protection, said he had not yet read the complaint. But, he said, the F.T.C. plans to soon release a report about online privacy because it is concerned about sensitive personal information.

Mr. Vladeck offered a hypothetical example of a core privacy question. “Suppose someone goes online to read about depression, should that person get targeted with ads for antidepressants, for counseling services or books about depression?”

9 comments:

  1. Please be aware of Hashmi Dawakhana’s sexual products. These are cheater no One. They are cheating to innocent people like me. I was also attracted and impressed by their advertisements and websites. I also got trapped by these thugs. Whatever they are promising on net like 2 inches increments in length and 50% increments in girth? These are all fake.

    I took full course of my treatment what I have achieved only 1 1/2 inches increments in length and 25% increments in girth. I was also expecting to be cured of my pre ejaculation.

    Please think over before making any decision.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My God, why oh why haven't I ordered the electric systems years ago??? It just arrived today, have it on now and can't believe what a big difference from the hand pump. So quiet, so comfortable and hands free. No more pumping to the vacuum where I want. Thanks dudes, great product as usual.
    There's always the worry that you'll be ripped off on the Internet, which is one reason why I haven't ordered anything from the net until now. With Vacu-Tech my fears were groundless as I just received today what I ordered on Monday and everything was in the package. I was so pleased that I just had to email you my thanks and will continue to order from you.


    Thank you
    Hashmi hakeem

    ReplyDelete
  3. These male extra pills really do work. I have been using them everyday with exercising and I have managed to grow my penis by nearly 1 inch.
    Great pills, I'm going to order some more.
    I have tried viagra in the past and these male extra pills are way better. I don't get a headache like I did with viagra but I can perform the same and last for much longer in bed.

    Thank you
    Hashmi herbalist
    http://doctoradvice.org

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dear Friends,

    Please be aware of Hashmi Dawakhana’s sexual products. They are cheating to innocent people like me. I was also attracted and impressed by their advertisements and lucrative websites. I also got trapped by these thugs. Whatever they are promising on net like - time period, erectile dysfunction and premature ejaculation, hardness, quantity of sperms and semen .These are all fakes.

    I took full course of Mughal-e-azam herbal capsule for my treatment. I have only cured with hardness & erectile dysfunction. I was expecting to be fully cured of my premature ejaculation problem but I got little improvement.

    Please think over before making any decision.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Friends,

    What I know is that hashmi dawa khana is cheating on peoples because I took skander-e-azam for 3 months but I did not notice any change in my penis.

    You are cheater why do you like to cheat on people. God will punish you sent me fake medicine.

    i used ur sikander-azam capsule i didnt get any benifit of like - 2 cm increment .ye galet baat hai..............

    I have only been cured with 1cm in length & premature ejaculation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Dear Friends,

    Please be aware of Hashmi Dawakhana’s health products. I was also attracted and impressed by their advertisements and lucrative websites. I also got trapped by these thugs. Whatever they are promising to gain weight quickly up to 10kg in one month but I gain only 5kg in one month period.

    I took full course of vitoll-xl to gain weight. I was expecting to be fully cured of my problem but I got little improvement.

    Please think before buying.

    Jay
    Nava Jivan Nagar
    Vakola Pipe Line
    Calcutta (India)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I decided to buy some penis enlargement pills after seeing a program on TV about size. The male extra ones looked the best so I bought a 4 months supply. The instructions say to take 3 pills a day, but sometimes I forgot so they lasted about a month longer.
    And now? Well, I can proudly say that i'm now the owner of a thick 7 inch penis. I've exercised everyday, taken the pills and grown just over an inch.



    Thank you
    Herbalist
    http://doctoradvice.org

    ReplyDelete
  8. "I have to tell you guys that the elliptical cylinder I received is the best...I have been pumping for many, many years and have NEVER had the results like I've had with this tube. The new elliptical cylinder gives me more pack that stays throughout my day. Thank You....It's the reason I constantly buy my tubes and pumps from you!"


    Thank you
    Herbalist
    http://dotoradvice.org

    ReplyDelete
  9. Dear Friends,

    I have purchased online Migrokill to cure my migraine. I have taken only one month course to cure my problem. I got little relief from this product.Please be aware of Hashmi Dawakhana’s health products. I was also attracted and impressed by their advertisements and lucrative websites. I also got trapped by these thugs.


    Please think before buying.

    Sanjeev Rayni
    Nava Jivan Nagar
    Vakola Pipe Line
    Calcutta (India)


    http://migraine-medicineonline.com/

    ReplyDelete